Goldmine Magazine: Monkees Reissue Reviews

Reissues: The Monkees
from Goldmine, March 17, 1995 and June 9, 1995

Rhino’s recent acquisition of the Monkees catalog is cause for joy and
merriment among fans of the first made-for-TV rock group. Rhino has been a
conspicuous friend to Monkees fans for over a decade (commencing with the
1982 picture disc “Monkee Business”), and the label has always treated the
Monkees with a level of respect that hasn’t always been easy to come by for
the much-maligned Prefab four.

“The Monkees,” “The Birds, The Bees & The Monkees” and “Changes” are the
first of three blocs of discs, reissuing the Monkees’ entire original
nine-album ’60s output. Each bloc includes one of the Monkees’ earliest
albums, one from the middle of their career and one from the later period,
after Peter Tork left the group in 1968. Each individual disc includes
bonus tracks (most previously unreleased), and the series as a whole is
already an immense improvement over Arista’s patchwork attempt to reissue
the Monkees albums on CD in the late ’80s.

[The second bloc includes “More Of The Monkees,” “Head” and “The Monkees
Present.”] As Rhino’s reissues come to a close [with the third block], we
see that they’ve saved two of the group’s best albums for last. 1969’s
“Instant Replay” may not be anyone’s favorite Monkees albums, but most
dedicated fans will probably point to either “Headquarters” or “Pisces,
Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.” (both from 1967) as the high-water mark in
the recording career of Micky, Davy, Peter and Michael.

The Monkees

The Monkees’ eponymous 1966 debut album has aged well. It’s a sprightly
collection of brisk pop that frolics joyfully under the benign influence of
the Beatles, the Byrds, the Beau Brummels, the Dave Clark Five and the Beach
Boys, roughly analogous to a less raucous Paul Revere and the Raiders or a
(much!) more rock-solid Herman’s Hermits. That’s pretty heady company to
keep, but the Monkees hold their own here.

The familiar “(Theme From) The Monkees” remains a delight, immediately
evocative of the light-hearted romps of the TV show. The obvious high point
is the chart-topping, “Paperback Writer”-derived “Last Train To
Clarksville,” but it’s joined by “I’ll Be True To You” (a British hit for
the Hollies as “Yes I Will”), “Saturday’s Child,” “Tomorrow’s Gonna Be
Another Day,” “This Just Doesn’t Seem To Be My Day,” the Carole King-Gerry
Goffin “Take A Giant Step” and Michael Nesmith’s “Sweet Young Thing”
(co-written with King and Goffin), each an effervescent example of pop song
craftsmanship.

There’s also country-tinged pop (nearly two years before the Byrds’
“Sweetheart Of The Rodeo,” mind you) in Nesmith’s “Papa Gene’s Blues,” and a
prototype for the Ramones in “Let’s Dance On.” Even the goofy “Gonna Buy Me
A Dog” and Davy Jones’s puppy-eyed “I Wanna Be Free” are basically
agreeable, although the Byrdsy alternate version of the latter song (found
on the “Missing Links, Volume Two” collection) remains the real keeper.

Bonus tracks on “The Monkees” are all previously-unreleased: an alternate
version of “I Can’t Get Her Off My Mind” (slightly smoother than the version
on the “Headquarters” LP), the always-wonderful “I Don’t Think You Know Me”
(the same backing track as the version on “Missing Links,” but with Micky
Dolenz’s vocals alternately replacing the mingling with Nesmith’s) and an
early version of “(Theme From) The Monkees” (with Boyce and Hart on vocals;
Dolenz is also credited, but not clearly audible).

More Of The Monkees

1967’s “More Of The Monkees,” the group’s second album, was by all accounts
immensely disliked by the Monkees themselves, particularly Michael Nesmith
(who once called it “probably the worst album in the history of the world”).
Much of the group’s distaste for the record can be attributed simply to
their lack of involvement in its creation, as it was assembled largely
without their input.

But for those of us on the outside looking in, time has been very kind to
“More Of The Monkees.” There are a few regrettable clunkers (“Your Auntie
Grizelda,” “Laugh” and the indescribably goopy “The Day We Fall In Love”),
but the set is otherwise filled with terrific songs and performances. Micky
Dolenz puts his best pout and sneer into “She” and “(I’m Not Your) Steppin’
Stone,” Boyce and Hart’s two classic punk tunes. Dolenz also shines on the
Nesmith-written “Mary, Mary,” the King-Goffin “Sometime In The Morning” and
Neil Diamond’s little-known (ahem) “I’m A Believer.”

“I’m A Believer” was the album’s big smash hit, but Davy Jones actually got
the better Diamond tune in the engagingly bouncy “Look Out (Here Comes
Tomorrow).” Jones is also allowed a couple of other decent tunes here, and
Nesmith contributes a rockin’ “The Kind Of Girl I Could Love.” But the
album as a whole belongs to Dolenz.

Bonus tracks on “More Of The Monkees” include a previously-unreleased
version of “Don’t Listen To Linda” (livelier than the subsequent version on
“Instant Replay”), the alternate version of “I’ll Spend My Life With You”
(previously issued on the “Listen To The Band” boxed set, and even better
than the version on “Headquarters”), a different mix of the Peter Tork-sung
“I Don’t Think You Know Me” from “Listen To The Band” and a great alternate
version of “Look Out (Here Comes Tomorrow),” ruined by a Tork voice-over
that somebody at some time must have thought was a good idea. The set
closes with an appealingly tentative take of “I’m A Believer.”

Headquarters

In the context of continuing complaints about how the Monkees weren’t a real
band (yawn) and they didn’t even play their own instruments for chrissakes,
“Headquarters” stands as the only album the Monkees ever made as a band:
Michael Nesmith on vocals, pedal steel guitar, six-string guitar and organ;
Davy Jones on vocals, tambourine, jawbone, maracas, etc.; Micky Dolenz on
vocals, drums and guitar; Peter Tork on vocals, keyboards, 12-string guitar,
bass and five-string banjo.

Not to belabor this point–even rock critics know this really doesn’t matter
by now–but the above credits mean that Dolenz was the only drummer on
“Headquarters.” Tork was the only keyboardist. Aside from assistance from
Jerry Yester and Keith Allison on one track (“No Time”), Nesmith, Tork and
Dolenz were the only guitarists.

Supplemented only by producer/fifth Monkee Chip Douglas on bass and by cello
and French Horn players on “Shades Of Gray,” the Monkees on “Headquarters”
were as much a “real” band as the Beatles or the Rolling Stones. Hell, they
were more of a “real” band here than the Beach Boys were on “Pet Sounds.”
Not bad for a bunch of TV idols with a manufactured image.

Sure, it’s all irrelevant. But “Headquarters’s” authenticity lends it a
hard-won aura of credibility. That gives it a special place in the hearts
of Monkees fans, but its virtues go beyond merely transcending the perceived
limitations of the Monkees’ artificial origins. It’s a terrific record, a
wonderful melange of pop, rock ‘n’ roll, folk and country influences.

Most of the album’s best moments are spearheaded by Nesmith, who pilots the
band through irresistible performances of his songs “You Told Me,” “Sunny
Girlfriend” and “You Just May Be The One.” Jones, perhaps physically
restrained from rendering any puppy-eyed ballads, turns in two of his best
vocal performances on the decidedly non-drippy “Forget That Girl” and “Early
Morning Blues And Greens.”

Still, the album’s best moment is probably “For Pete’s Sake,” a wonderful
peace-and-love anthem co-written by Tork (with Joseph Richards) and sung
winningly by Dolenz. It’s chiefly remembered as the closing theme for The
Monkees TV series’s second season, but it should have been a single.

(The album’s weak moments? There aren’t any. Even the goofy larks “Zilch”
and “Band 6,” Nesmith and Dolenz’s inept attempt to play the Looney Tunes
cartoon theme, are diverting and agreeable.)

Bonus tracks on “Headquarters” include two more tracks by the Monkees band
(with John London on bass): the previously-unissued single mix of “All Of
Your Toys” and a previously-unissued Nesmith-sung version of “The Girl I
Knew Somewhere.” Both of these fit in perfectly with the original album.
There’s also Nesmith’s solo take on his own “Nine Times Blue,” a Tork
instrumental (a weird version of “Peter Gunn”), an impromptu singalong of
the traditional “Jericho” and a revealing listen to Dolenz in the studio,
chatting with Douglas and singing “Pillow Time.”

Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.

The Monkees retired the group concept for “Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn &
Jones Ltd.,” though the individual Monks [sic] still played alongside a
varied selection of studio personnel on scattered tracks. The result
remains the single strongest Monkees album, simply loaded with great tracks:
“The Door Into Summer,” “Love Is Only Sleeping,” Harry Nilsson’s “Cuddly
Toy,” “Words,” “Pleasant Valley Sunday,” the self-consciously psychedelic
“Daily Nightly,” “Star Collector” and, best of all, Michael Martin Murphy
and Owens Castleman’s incomparable “What Am I Doing Hangin’ ‘Round?”

Unlike “Headquarters,” “PAC&J Ltd.” does suffer from a couple of sub-par
tracks in Jones’s once-more-into-the-drippy “Hard To Believe” and Tork’s
annoyingly cutesy spoken-word “Peter Percival Patterson’s Pet Pig Porky.”
Bonus tracks offer previously-unissued mixes of “Goin’ Down,” “Salesman,”
“The Door Into Summer,” “Love Is Only Sleeping,” “Daily Nightly” and “Star
Collector,” plus another spoken-word piece by Tork. On the negative side,
this was the album that introduced the dreaded Moog synthesizer to pop
music, but the statute of limitations has passed on that particular Crime
Against Humanity.

The Birds, The Bees & The Monkees

1968’s “The Birds, The Bees & The Monkees” is ambitious, though not quite in
the same league as any of the four Monkees albums that preceded it. Time
has been kind to its virtues–it’s a perfect encapsulation of the
prototypical low-key late ’60s pop album–but its excesses are still
evident.

Nesmith contributes equally to the album’s success and failure ratio. On
“The Birds, The Bees & The Monkees,” Nesmith took full advantage of the
relative freedom that the then-new “produced by the Monkees” recording
policy offered him. His contributions here range from indulgent (the
interminable “Writing Wrongs” and the campy “Magnolia Simms”) to
accomplished (“Tapioca Tundra” and the Dolenz-sung “Auntie’s Municipal
Court”). Aside from “Tapioca Tundra,” none of this really ranks with
Nesmith’s best Monkees work.

As for the other Monkees, Tork is effectively shut out here, his only
appearance on the original album limited to playing piano on “Daydream
Believer.” Dolenz’s breathy vocals grace three winning tracks–“Auntie’s
Municipal Court,” “I’ll Be Back Up On My Feet” and the simplistic but
effective “Zor And Zam”–plus the not-bad “P.O. Box 9847.” As for Jones,
his prerequisite drippy ballad–“We Were Made For Each Other”–isn’t really
all that drippy, while “Dream World” and “The Poster” (both co-written by
Jones with Steve Pitts) are decent straight pop. And the hits–“Daydream
Believer” and the dynamic, perennially underrated “Valleri”–are hits to
sing forevermore.

Bonus tracks: Tork makes his belated appearance on “The Birds, The Bees &
The Monkees” with a short spoken-word piece (“Alvin”) and an alternate
version of his easy-going but undistinguished “Lady’s Baby.” There’s also
an alternate mix of “P.O. Box 9847,” and two more Jones tracks: the
previously-unreleased “I’m Gonna Try” and an alternate version of “The Girl
I Left Behind Me,” which beats the version on the “Instant Replay” album
hands down.

Head

“Head,” the 1968 soundtrack to the Monkees only movie (so far), remains as
loopy and weird as the film itself. Amidst a collage of audio snippets from
the movie, six actual songs emerge. Chief among these is the gorgeous
Goffin-King “Porpoise Song,” which is one of the most majestic tracks ever
done under the Monkees’ aegis. Each of the six songs on “Head” is a worthy
effort, but “Porpoise Song” and the lovely Goffin-King “As We Go Along”
simply tower above the rest.

Of the other songs, Jones’s much-maligned take on Nilsson’s “Daddy’s Song”
is a perfectly engaging guilty pleasure, Nesmith’s studio “Circle Sky” lacks
the bite of the now-familiar live version (included as one of the bonus
tracks here) and Tork’s “Long Title: Do I Have To Do This All Over Again”
and “Can You Dig It” (the latter sung by Dolenz) offer a heavier sound than
that usually associated with the Monkees. And, although not really a song,
“Ditty Diego — War Chant” deconstructs the Monkees’ image, origins, career
and reasons for existing with hysteric delight.

Aside from the live “Circle Sky,” other bonus tracks include a revealing
early work-in-progress version of “Ditty Diego — War Chant” (coached by
“album coordinator” Jack Nicholson), replete with an extra verse and
uncluttered by varispeed effects. There’s also a Tork-sung version of “Can
You Dig It,” a Nesmith-sung version of “Daddy’s Song,” a rendition of “Happy
Birthday To You” from the movie and a “Head” radio spot. In its expanded
form, “Head” remains a trip. (Though it’s too bad Rhino couldn’t figure out
a way to reproduce the original album’s mylar-mirror cover. Or maybe not.)

(Note: At this writing, the film itself is due for imminent reissue from
Rhino Home Video. Even if you’re not a Monkees fan, “Head” is one of the
most gleefully subversive rock movies ever made, and is well worth your
time.)

Instant Replay

“Instant Replay,” the first Monkees album released after Tork left the fold
in 1968, is obviously in a different class from “Headquarters” and “Pisces,
Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.” It’s not a bad album, but the high points
aren’t quite as high as before, and there are fewer of them. The best track
is Jones’s “You And I,” a rockin’ little number flavored with some tasty
Neil Young guitar.

Nesmith also contributes some satisfying, low-key country pop, and “Tear
Drop City” is acceptable as the brazen “Last Train To Clarksville” retread
it is. The rest is largely forgettable, with Dolenz’s interminable,
self-indulgent “Shorty Blackwell” the album’s nadir.

The non-LP single “Someday Man” leads off the bonus tracks. It’s joined by
alternate versions of Nesmith’s “Carlisle Wheeling” (which he later redid
post-Monkees under the title “Conversations”) and Dolenz’s “Rosemarie,” plus
Jones’s previously-unissued (and not bad) “Smile.” Alternate mixes of “St.
Matthew,” “Me Without You” and “Through The Looking Glass” bring the disc to
its conclusion.

The Monkees Present

1969’s “The Monkees Present” (by the Monkee trio of Dolenz, Jones and
Nesmith–Tork left after “Head”) is a generally overlooked item in the
group’s album catalog. Oh, there’s some genuine drek here, notably
Nesmith’s wacky “Never Tell A Woman Yes” (it’s flabbergasting to consider
the many fine Nesmith tracks that were left in the vault at the time in
favor of this!) and Jones’s take on Boyce and Hart’s just-plain-dumb “Ladies
Aid Society.”

But there are also some real gems. Two of Nesmith’s very best country
tunes, “Good Clean Fun” and “Listen To The Band,” are here, aided and
abetted by his lively take on Michael Martin Murphy’s “Oklahoma Backroom
Dancer.” Dolenz contributes three fine originals: the exquisite “Little
Girl” (with some mesmerizing, jazzy guitar courtesy of Louie Shelton), “Bye
Bye Baby Bye Bye” and the heavy-handed social commentary of “Mommy And
Daddy.” Jones doesn’t fare quite as well, but “If I Knew” is agreeable
enough, and he’s fully redeemed via “Looking For The Good Times,” a very
nice track that dates back to the “More Of The Monkees” sessions.

Bonus tracks: the previously-unreleased “Calico Girlfriend Samba” (later
recut by Nesmith solo), an alternate version of “Listen To The Band” and a
radio spot for the album. The two other bonus tracks represent polar
extremes in approach. “The Good Earth,” a spoken-word piece by Jones, is
the sort of self-important sentiment that rock writers generally prefer to
rip to shreds, burn to a crisp and piddle on the smoldering ashes. This
writer, preparing to welcome his first child into the world and actively
searching for some sign that there’ll be a good Earth for that child to live
in, found it affecting and moving. So there.

On the other hand, the alternate version of “Mommy And Daddy” is genuinely
shocking, primarily for the incongruity of these incendiary alternate lyrics
offered by one of the nice ‘n’ cuddly Monkees. A terrific cut, but we can
practically guarantee you won’t believe the Monkees actually did this.
Yikes! And we mean it, man — yikes!

Changes

>From 1970, “Changes” features just Dolenz and Jones and was the last
original album released under the Monkees’ name until 1987’s “Pool It!”
“Changes” has long been considered the low point of the Monkees’ recording
career, but it has its moments. The opener, “Oh My My,” is a splendidly
soulful single that should have been a hit. And “I Love You Better” is a
good example of radio-ready bubblegum, vaguely reminiscent of Neil Diamond’s
early singles.

Meanwhile, Jones rocks out half-convincingly on the dumb-but-endearing “99
Pounds,” while “I Never Thought It Peculiar” fulfills the dreaded Guilty
Pleasure spot: it’s a gawky, guileless Boyce-Hart pop tune, devoid of
definable merit yet utterly, utterly charming. Dolenz’s bubblesoul vocals
almost save “Tell Me Love” (why didn’t this guy have AM radio hits in the
’70s?!), and Jones’s essential cuddliness redeems “Do You Feel It Too?”

But too much of this stuff is lame and faceless, more suited to the bland
pop stylings of Andy Kim and Bobby Bloom (both of whom were involved in
making “Changes”) than to the Monkees. It’s no real surprise that this
album was effectively the Monkees’ swan song.

“Changes'” bonus tracks are all previously-released; attempts to come up
with unreleased tracks from the vault–specifically, “Which Way Do You Want
It” and “Ride Baby Ride,” which were recorded during the “Changes”
sessions–came up empty. Instead, we have the appealingly atmospheric “Time
And Time Again” (previously issued on “Missing Links”) and both sides of a
1971 Micky Dolenz and Davy Jones single, “Do It In The Name Of Love” and
“Lady Jane,” the latter of which has never been reissued before.

Conclusion

Typical of Rhino reissues, each of these discs sports very nice liner notes
and clean sound, and each is assembled with evident care and affection.

Although this completes the reissues of the Monkees’ original albums, Rhino
has promised a new greatest-hits set, a third volume of “Missing Links”
(yay!) and even, to the horror of many, an expanded reissue of 1987’s “Pool
It!” One hopes that the unreleased 1970 live album mentioned in the booklet
to the “Listen To The Band” boxed set will also finally see the light of
day.

But whatever happens vis-a-vis future Monkees releases, faithful fans hereby
doff their caps to the good folks at Rhino. In a cruel pop world that feels
no obligation to even acknowledge the viability of the Monkees’ recorded
legacy, Rhino’s fine efforts are certainly appreciated. MonkeeMen, away!

— Carl Cafarelli